Rating NFL New Head Coaches: Genius Hires, Wild Gambles, and Whole Shrugs

The Caesars Superdome in New Orleans will home a Tremendous Bowl-winning head coach come Sunday night time.

The Saints are anticipated to rent somebody who aspires to that title quickly after.

Six of the NFL’s seven head-coaching vacancies are stuffed, and we’ll name {that a} quorum for rating the hires up to now.

Right here goes. 

NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS: MIKE VRABEL

Patriots followers know their former linebacker received as a participant—three Tremendous Bowls, in truth, however who’s counting? However Vrabel brings a robust teaching background to this homecoming dance, too.

Vrabel guided the Tennessee Titans to a few playoff appearances in six seasons and takes over a gaggle with promising youth. An infusion of tradition is so as in New England, although, and Vrabel has a background there.

After inconsistency within the lone season underneath one other former Pats LB, Jerod Mayo, count on Vrabel to emphasize accountability whereas shifting the group ahead.

CHICAGO BEARS: BEN JOHNSON

The Bears solid a remarkably extensive internet of their teaching search and will really feel giddy about touchdown one of many proverbial large fish within the cycle. Johnson would arguably rank forward of Vrabel if not for the latter’s confirmed previous.

As it’s, this first-time head coach is a seasoned, progressive offensive coordinator who has steered the division rival Detroit Lions to new heights. Heaven is aware of the Bears desperately may use some creativeness on offense, and with 2024 prime decide Caleb Williams exhibiting flashes in his rookie season at quarterback, the chances are possible, if not infinite.

Managing the remainder of what comes with being a head coach is subsequent.

NEW YORK JETS: AARON GLENN

Jets proprietor Woody Johnson has proven an affinity for first-time head coaches, however Glenn isn’t the backyard selection in that division. 

His 4 seasons as Detroit Lions defensive coordinator got here because the group rose from dormancy to relevancy, for one. Glenn is also a former defensive again and favourite son of Gang Inexperienced, for whom he was a first-round decide in 1994.

Glenn brings a robust persona and budding resume to a company that faces a 14-season playoff drought and uncertainty underneath middle. His work is lower out for him, however he’s proven he’ll be as much as it.

JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS: LIAM COEN

The route wasn’t precisely an easy one, however the Jaguars in the end landed one of many extra well-publicized coordinators who didn’t name Detroit residence in 2024.

Now the group should hope it’s getting the Coen who helped jolt the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Baker Mayfield final season. He’s preferable to the Coen who was the Los Angeles Rams OC in 2022, when the Male Sheep have been final within the league in yardage.

Jacksonville wants creativeness for a stumbling assault with younger ability. Quarterback Trevor Lawrence nonetheless is barely 25. There’s purpose to consider Coen will convey a spark. Solely factor is, his observe file isn’t particularly prolonged.

LAS VEGAS RAIDERS: PETE CARROLL

Sure ideas and pictures take maintain once you point out Carroll. Power and a few type of motivational quip to start out.

These issues nonetheless maintain true for Carroll, who’ll flip 74 on the finish of Week 2, however the thought of seeing him on a Tremendous Bowl sideline once more appears dicey. Being the NFL’s oldest head coach has nothing to do with it.

Las Vegas faces a substantial rebuild within the locker room and roster, the place main questions at quarterback loom. The Raiders additionally reside within the rugged AFC West, whose different three groups made the playoffs in 2024. Carroll’s expertise and pep should be positives for first-time GM John Spytek, however this nonetheless seems like a transitional transfer to arrange Carroll’s successor.

DALLAS COWBOYS: BRIAN SCHOTTENHEIMER

If this have been an train in letter grades, Dallas’ rent would match the town’s nickname and charge a “Large D.”

Whereas Schottenheimer brings a robust pedigree and greater than twenty years of teaching expertise within the league, he doesn’t precisely tote the type of cachet for which the fan base clamors. Weren’t Vrabel, Johnson, and Glenn out there? Completely. However as a result of the Cowboys parted methods with Mike McCarthy so late within the teaching cycle, they weren’t ready to interview many large names.

Schottenheimer spent the previous three seasons with Dallas, together with the final two as offensive coordinator. That bodes properly for rejuvenating a recuperating Dak Prescott underneath middle, however Schottenheimer ought to know greater than most how Dallas faces quite a few different points.